Cheap Car Insurance in New York for December 2025 - NerdWallet To get an idea of what the cheapest insurance company is in your part of New York, shop around for quotes before buying a policy NerdWallet analyzed rates for 18 insurers to find the cheapest
Best Cheap Car Insurance in Brooklyn, NY, From $231 Brooklyn drivers pay more for car insurance than drivers in the rest of the Empire State But drivers may still find good deals with Travelers, Safeco, and Nationwide